• Home
  • Image Galleries
  • Forum
  • Polls
  • Rivers & Streams
    • River Almond
  • Fishery Information
    • Allandale Tarn
    • Bangour Trout Fishery
    • Beecraigs Trout Fishing
    • Bowden Springs Trout Fishery
    • Crosswood Trout Fishery
    • Harburn Trout Fishery
    • Harperigg Fisheries
    • Morton Trout Fishery
    • Pottishaw Fly Fishery
    • Selmmuir Trout Fishery
    • Beyond West Lothian
      • Hillend Loch
  • Weather
  • Links
  • Contact Us
Site Navigation
  • Home
  • Fishing Blogs
  • Recent posts
  • Groups
User login
  • Create new account
  • Request new password


Selmmuir Fly Fishing Shop

New groups
  • FFWL Fly Tying Group
  • River Almond Anglers Group
Latest image
quill klink
Random image
One on a spider (linhouse)

Crosswood Trout Fishery

Poll
What's the best general purpose setup for small rivers ?
7ft #3/4
33%
8ft #4/5
56%
9ft #5/6
11%
Total votes: 9
PostCommentsIcon 4 comments  | Older polls
Who's new
  • tam
  • Colin Carnie
  • Bell_James
  • rab tennant
  • flydrowner
Who's online
There are currently 3 users and 1 guest online.

Online users

  • Sandmac
  • Douglas_Admin
  • rab tennant
Countdown
4 days, 13 hours, 29 minutes until The Start Of The 2010 Brown Trout Season..
Home
PostCommentsIcon Login or register to post comments
6 replies [Last post]
Thu, 06/25/2009 - 10:53
Douglas_Admin
Getting very excited about the new season
Douglas_Admin's picture
User is online Online
Joined: 01/23/2009
Points: 378
Groups: FFWL Fly Tying Group, River Almond Anglers Group

I have not fished with a Booby for probably 15 years but that's through choice. Why is this fly in particular singled out by fisheries as the one to ban ?.

It puzzles me that this fly should be outlawed, is it because of it's killer reputation ?. Looking at the design of the Booby it does not appear to represent more danger to the fish, it is at the end of the day a hook with some dressing like any other fly.

With the advent of hooked indicators and Blobs, perhaps it's time to set the Booby free.

__________________

A frightening future - The Obama Deception

Top
PostCommentsIcon Login or register to post comments
Thu, 06/25/2009 - 11:02
#1
Sandmac
does not have a status.
Sandmac's picture
User is online Online
Joined: 01/26/2009
Points: 45
Groups: River Almond Anglers Group
I Agree

I have used this fly a few times in the past and dont understand why it is banned from most fisherie's.
It is a very good fly for the end of a washing line with dropper's.

FREE THE BOOBIES

Top
PostCommentsIcon Login or register to post comments
Thu, 06/25/2009 - 14:56
#2
wildfisher
does not have a status.
wildfisher's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 hour 44 min ago. Offline
Joined: 03/19/2009
Points: 265
Groups: FFWL Fly Tying Group, River Almond Anglers Group
Outlawed !

I think they were banned on some fisheries because of the way they were fished , ie short lenghth of mono hi d line and fished static, you could almost give some anglers a rod rest, this in a lot of cases led to deep hooking , but on a kill ticket i dont see the problem, although the method its probaby more related to bait fishing than active fly fishing. i know they can be fished in many differant ways though , on differant densities of line and thisformof fishing is actually quite skilled. Ive never used them myself , but its just another fly at the end of the day. Lots of flies have been banned on lots of waters at some time. Nymphs on chalksteams and even the Alexandra was banned because of its knack of catching fish.

Top
PostCommentsIcon Login or register to post comments
Thu, 06/25/2009 - 15:41
#3
Douglas_Admin
Getting very excited about the new season
Douglas_Admin's picture
User is online Online
Joined: 01/23/2009
Points: 378
Groups: FFWL Fly Tying Group, River Almond Anglers Group
Maybe the method ?

I have seen it fished deep and static before and this does lead to deep hooking but I have always considered it a dry fly. It's not a fly I have fished often but I would fish it if it were allowed, I would fish it on the surface as a single or as part of a team. Maybe the method of fishing it on a short leader, deep and static should be banned and not the fly itself.

I'm sure fishing it on the surface would induce some awesome takes from Rainbows as Woolly Buggers do fished just under the surface given the right conditions.

Top
PostCommentsIcon Login or register to post comments
Thu, 06/25/2009 - 15:53
#4
wildfisher
does not have a status.
wildfisher's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 hour 44 min ago. Offline
Joined: 03/19/2009
Points: 265
Groups: FFWL Fly Tying Group, River Almond Anglers Group
try a zonker!

One of the places i fished when i frequented rainbow waters over 10 years ago now was beleive it or not was Selmiur, one hatch that used to give fantastic rises was the caenis fly, it was difficult fishing if trying to match the hatch and as they were cruising just inches under the surface their window of vision was very small plus the needle in a haystack scenario with millions of naturals to your artificial . A natural grey coloured(Actually probably any colour) zonker(rabbit strip has natural bouyancy)fished with a fastish figure of 8 retreive would catch their eye resulting in lots of follows and some exciting takes, give it a go.

Top
PostCommentsIcon Login or register to post comments
Fri, 06/26/2009 - 20:34
#5
jameswmcl
does not have a status.
User offline. Last seen 4 weeks 6 days ago. Offline
Joined: 06/19/2009
Points: 0
Groups: None
just my opinion boobies

just my opinion

boobies fished like bait = poaching

Top
PostCommentsIcon Login or register to post comments
Sun, 06/28/2009 - 08:03
#6
Douglas_Admin
Getting very excited about the new season
Douglas_Admin's picture
User is online Online
Joined: 01/23/2009
Points: 378
Groups: FFWL Fly Tying Group, River Almond Anglers Group
Poaching

I don't consider the use of any fly to be poaching, I guess if it's not allowed or if you are fishing without a permit your breaking rules but poaching is a bit far.

I understand the argument against Boobies but I think it would better serve anglers if the method of fishing them deep and static were outlawed rather than the fly itself.

Would anybody object if it were pike and not Rainbows???

Top
PostCommentsIcon Login or register to post comments
AddThis
Shout Box
Douglas_Admin:

no date has been set yet but it should be soon i think

Sandmac:

any rough idea when they open? i think i will go and have a look up there tonight

Douglas_Admin:

or if they'll price the tickets in a similar way.

Login or register to post shouts
All Shouts
New forum topics
  • Shakespeare Omni Bargain.
  • Access to rivers and burns.
  • No forum access from other P.Cs
  • Short Videos
  • Decline of the March Brown
  • Roadkill
  • Okuma 5wt fly reel for sale
  • snowbee rod holder
  • Intermediate or Sinking line.
  • Ticket price updates
more
Recent blog posts
  • 6'6" #2 2 peice rod build (update)
  • 6'6" #2 2 peice rod build
  • selmmuir fly tying night thursday 18/3/10
  • Killandean
  • First Outing For 2010
  • anyone sellin a rod?
  • Almond Pool Clean-up Operation. River Almond Anglers Group (RAAG)
  • fly tying night at selmmuir 17/2/10
  • Test the mobile version of FFWL!!
  • species caught to date
more

Terms & Conditions of Use
privacy Policy

©2009 FFWL - Maintained by Uinfix